Actors Who Turned Down Roles That Became Famous

Actors Who Turned Down Roles

Professional actors don’t take every acting role they are offered. They actually turn down some. When they do, it might be because of their tight schedule, the pay is not good enough, or even because they don’t like the script, or they don’t consider it good enough.

Now, sometimes, actors can be right when they judge the quality of a script or story to be below par. But then sometimes, they can be wrong, in that, that script or story line that didn’t make sense enough to them, end up becoming iconic.

In this article, we will examine five times this has happened. We will take a look at five actors who turned down roles that went on to become famous. Let’s dive right in!

Will Smith

  • Movie: The Matrix (1999)
  • Role: Neo
  • Cast Actor: Keanu Reeves

This is probably one of the most talked-about what ifs in Hollywood history. At the time when Matrix was going to be produced, Will Smith was at the peak of his blockbuster run. He had already featured in hits like Independence Day and Men in Black. So, when the Wachowskis approached him for The Matrix, he was actually their first choice for Neo.

But then, Smith turned down the role. And according to him, he didn’t really get what the movie was about. The Wachowskis tried to explain the concept to him, but he still didn’t think it made enough sense. So, instead of playing Neo, he chose to star in Wild Wild West, which, in hindsight, didn’t exactly hit the same cultural heights.

Matrix, as you would have known, went on to become a genre-defining film. And a huge part of that success was Keanu Reeves, whose calm, almost introspective performance as Neo perfectly matched the film’s tone. It’s hard to imagine anyone else in that role now.

John Travolta

  • Movie: Forrest Gump (1994)
  • Role: Forrest Gump
  • Cast Actor: Tom Hanks

The role of Forrest Gump in the movie, Forest Gump, was actually first offered to John Travolta. At the time, Travolta was really looking for opportunities to revive his career, and luckily enough he had two options to choose from. One of them was Forest Gump, and the other was Quentin Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction.

Travolta chose Pulp Fiction. And to be fair, that decision paid off. The film became a cultural phenomenon, and Travolta’s role as Vincent Vega landed him an Oscar nomination, and completely revived his career.

Meanwhile, Forrest Gump went on to become one of the most beloved films of all time. And Tom Hanks delivered a performance so iconic that it earned him an Academy Award and permanently tied him to the character.

Emily Blunt

  • Movie: Iron Man 2 (2010)
  • Role: Black Widow
  • Cast Actress: Scarlett Johansson.

In this case, Emily Blunt didn’t exactly turn down the role, she was kind of forced to. At the time, Blunt was signed to 20th Century Fox, and part of that agreement required her to star in Gulliver’s Travels. Because of that obligation, she had to pull out of Iron Man 2, even though she was set to make her debut as Black Widow.

Just like that, the door opened for Scarlett Johansson, and what followed was history. Johansson didn’t just play Black Widow in Iron Man 2; she went on to become one of the central figures in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, appearing across multiple films and eventually leading her own standalone movie.

Jack Nicholson

  • Movie: The Godfather (1972)
  • Role: Michael Corleone
  • Cast Actor: Al Pacino

At the time The Godfather was being cast, Jack Nicholson was already a rising star, and Paramount Pictures reportedly preferred a more established name to lead the film as Michael Corleone. Nicholson was approached, but he turned it down. And his reason was surprisingly straightforward.

He believed that Italian characters should be played by Italian actors. In his words, “Indians should play Indians and Italians should play Italians.” So instead of stepping into the role, he passed on it entirely.

That decision opened the door for a relatively unknown Al Pacino at the time. And what followed was nothing short of legendary. Al Pacino’s portrayal of Michael Corleone, especially his transformation from a reluctant outsider to a cold, calculated mafia boss, became one of the greatest performances in film history.

Matt Damon

  • Movie: Avatar (2009)
  • Role: Jake Sully
  • Cast Actor: Sam Worthington

Matt Damon was offered the lead role of Jake Sully in Avatar by James Cameron. At the time, Cameron was building what would eventually become a groundbreaking sci-fi epic, but it was still a risky, highly ambitious project that hadn’t proven itself yet.

Damon, however, had a prior commitment. He was deeply tied to the Bourne franchise and chose to honor that obligation instead of jumping onto Avatar. On the surface, it sounds like a reasonable and respectable decision.

But here’s where it stings a little. Cameron didn’t just offer Damon the role, he reportedly offered him 10% of the film’s profits. Now consider this: Avatar went on to become one of the highest-grossing films of all time. That 10%? It’s widely estimated to be in the region of $250 million.

The Roles That Found Their Perfect Fit

Many of these decisions might look like a mistake on the part of the actors who passed on the roles. But then, when you look at the success that came out of the actors who eventually took them, it becomes difficult to imagine those films turning out the same way.